Catalyst Notebook Blog
Return To Main Blog Page
Organizing charter teachers, Chicago style Posted By John Myers On Wednesday, April 8, 2009
In Teachers

When teaching loads spiked last year, teachers at three Chicago International Charter Schools decided they needed a more formalized role in school management. Months later—after quietly organizing and pressing their peers to sign union cards—the formation of Chicago’s first charter school teachers union is but a step away.

Should the state’s Labor Board rule that the teachers followed protocol in their bid to unionize, they will begin crafting a new labor contract that will largely come to define their sought after “voice” in school decision making.

The nature of that contract and how closely it resembles traditional teachers union contracts will be closely watched by national observers, from advocates to agnostics in the highly partisan world of teachers unions and charter schools. Simply put, a tiny sliver of the nearly 4,000 charter schools across America are unionized and there are precious few examples of how to marry job protections and other benefits afforded to unionized teachers with the operational flexibility that charters like to trumpet.

“It’s been all consuming just getting the cards signed,” says Emily Mueller, a Spanish teacher at the Chicago International-Northtown campus who played a central role in the union drive. “Just talking about contract issues seems like a major relief.”

Some charters, like the Green Dot schools that originated in Los Angles, started up as unionized shops and feature lightweight contracts that give principals substantial hiring and firing authority in exchange for higher teacher pay and clear pathways for influencing curricular and other educational choices.

Other charters, like two schools started recently by the United Federation of Teachers in New York, have looked for new ways to run schools while sticking to the rules laid out in the traditional UFT contract. Indeed, teachers at the schools have staggered their class schedules to provide a longer school day for children—without violating the limits on working hours spelled out in their union contract.

Illinois law forbids Mueller and the other Chicago International teachers from adopting the local contract used by the Chicago Teachers Union. But, if union rights are granted, the teachers will also not be starting from scratch. They will join a network of about 70 charter schools organized by the American Federation of Teachers called the Alliance of Charter Teachers and Administrators (ACTS).

According to an AFT official, about a third of the schools operate under pre-existing local labor contracts, another third use modified contracts and the rest have struck their own labor accords.

During the union push, Mueller admits that some teachers worried about creating a working environment that was complicated by union rules, especially anything that might cap the amount of time that teachers can spend working with children and parents.

But it was workload that catalyzed the unionization push. Civitas Schools, the education management group that runs Northtown and the two other Chicago International charters that may unionize, faced a tightening budget and asked teachers to teach an additional class, Mueller contends. She says class sizes have also increased.

“It’s just kind of exhausting,” she says. “And it’s hard to get to all the phone calls [to parents] that I need to make.”

The lightweight Green Dot contracts do not stipulate the number of hours that teachers work, but teachers are generally paid competitive wages as a result.

Mueller also says she hopes that her school’s focus on using student test score results to direct instructional strategies will also not be impacted by contract talks. But some of her peers, she admits, think that school administrators focus too much on tests.

It’s unclear how such issues will be tackled contractually. But Mueller says: “Nothing is going to happen during negotiations that the teachers are not in favor of.”

Bread and butter issues will also crop up, of course.

Chicago International teachers are paid competitively in their early years, but salary ranges do not keep up with the step and lane increases afforded to CTU members and suburban school teachers. That has lead to teacher turnover issues, according to both Mueller and a top-ranking Chicago International administrator.

Mueller says the increased teaching load only exacerbated turnover at her school. The gravity of the problem, she adds, forced teachers to sit down and discuss unionization. They contacted a CTU member and started getting help from ACTS soon after.

Interestingly, the higher turnover has also been a major roadblock for unionizing the charter schools. Mueller says teachers have to stay around long enough to form a critical mass of union activists.

Union organizers felt a “great sense of urgency” to finish the campaign because, beginning this spring, teachers will be signing individual contracts with Civitas and committing to teaching another year. Who stays and who goes could affect the teacher count that is central to getting the Labor Board’s approval for forming a union.

“It was kind of like now or never,” she says.




Comments
Wed Apr 8, 2009 at 9:20 PMBy: Colleague Organizing charter teachers, Chicago style The Civitas organizational management's administrators pushed test score results hard, impacting the climate of their schools. They also completed surveys with staff, still not seeming to hear what the teachers were saying. Turnover at the Civitas organization itself, has also been very concerning.
Thu Apr 9, 2009 at 9:19 AMBy: Civitas Teacher Thank you to our organizers I'm proud of all Civitas teachers who had the courage to sign and Emily Mueller for all of her direct and articluate comments in this article. I'm also proud to be part of a Union again and so proud of our organizers and grateful for all of their hardwork in paving the way for us. I back them up completely.

People have a right to organize if they are being exploited. Civitas teachers were being exploited and overworked in a sweatshop atmosphere. Our new Union is going to pave the way for the future of Northtown Academy and all Charter schools. Maybe in the future the school will be able to keep a few teachers more than a year or two. Job well done.
Thu Apr 9, 2009 at 9:27 AMBy: Turvover at top Organizing charter teachers, Chicago style The turn over at CIVITAS higher ups is also concerning. There is a new CEO, new principals, assistance principals leaving without notice, no assistance principal at one school. An organization in a mess. Hopefully both sides can sit down and start to bargain in a fair and agreeable fashion.
Thu Apr 9, 2009 at 2:09 PMBy: Doc Organizing charter teachers, Chicago style Congratulations on unionizing charter schools. Now they can focus on making teachers happy and do as poor a job educating students as do the CPS unionized schools. Oh, and God forbid that schools should use student performance data to evaulate teacher performance......after all, teachers are not there to educate students...they are there to make excuses for why students cannot be taught and to earn enough money to send their own children to private schools.
Thu Apr 9, 2009 at 3:58 PMBy: Rod Estvan Organizing charter teachers, Chicago style Much thanks to John Myers for his very well done article.
Thu Apr 9, 2009 at 6:36 PMBy: Northtown teacher Organizing charter teachers, Chicago style Doc,

You must have a pretty low opinion of the teachers at the Civitas schools to think that giving them the power to negotiate the conditions of their labor would lower the quality of the education they provide.

What, specifically, is wrong with them? Are they selfish and lazy? Do they have bad judgment? Do they hate the students?

What?

Please enlighten us.
Thu Apr 9, 2009 at 7:17 PMBy: Northtown Teacher Fan Organizing charter teachers, Chicago style The passion of the Northtown Academy Teachers is inspiring, in spite of the difficult organizational year they have experienced. Test scores have gone up, in spite of everything. The culture of the campus has always risen above the challenges placed before them. It's about time that the management organization gets baptized with new people. Hopefully the management's curriculum directors will also improve with new talented, credentialled, administrative leaders who will lead positively and collaboratively, in spite of the old curricular materials that are out of date, with over paid consultants who have barely participated in curricular efforts.
Fri Apr 10, 2009 at 6:41 AMBy: Former Superintendent Organizing charter teachers, Chicago style Are the Civitas teachers negotiating with Civitas or CICS? If CICS decided to remove Civitas as an EMO of CICS would the negotiations still be valid, if a school was transfered to another EMO would the teachers still have jobs would they have to interview with the new EMO? Would CICS see the unionzation of 3 campuses as a threat to the other 9. Lets say that Civitas teachers get all they want by May 1st. Could CICS transfer over all Civitas Schools to another EMO on May 2nd and then the teachers would have a union but not a job. I was told that at one point Civitas had 4 schools and now has 3 because CICS gave the fourth school to another EMO. What is to stop them from giving all three away, is there a process? I am of the impression that all teacher contracts are with Civitas and not the CICS and that Civitas signs the checks and not CICS. Is there a clause in the contracts that says if something happens to the schools or if Civitas loses the schools under its control than the contracts are not enforceable? I would encourage the Civitas teachers to explore the relationship between CICS and Civitas and find out how quickly or what the terms that CICS could transfer schools away from Civitas. I would imagine that there would be some language that gives CICS flexability to change course in the event of a major concern with Civitas management of there schools, or something that can not be reconciled. This usually involves finances, how is Civitas doing, are they fiscally sound or are they in the red? It would be my hope that the Civitas teachers do not find themselves with an unenforceable contract if CICS changes course on Civitas.
Sat Apr 11, 2009 at 2:20 PMBy: To Northtown Fan re: Test Scores Organizing charter teachers, Chicago style Dear Northtown Fan: You state that "Test scores have gone up, in spite of everything." Here are Northtown's ACT composites, starting with 2004 and ending with 2008. 18.3, 19.3, 18.9, 19.9, 19.0. In 2008, that put Northtown at a "tie" for highest ACT composites with CMSA among charter high schools with juniors in 2008. At the same time, Northtown enrolls the fewest low-income students (in 2008, 58%, up from 51% the previous year according to ONS performance report) as compared to other charter high schools with juniors.
Test scores aren't everything, but when cited, please take care to do so accurately.
The 5-year data looks erratic. What are your thoughts? Could that be tied to factors noted above, such as high teacher/admin turnover, over-emphasis on test prep, lack of cohesive curricular vision, etc?
Sat Apr 11, 2009 at 2:29 PMBy: ex-Charter Teacher Organizing charter teachers, Chicago style Mr. Myers: Job well done on this article. I've often wondered if high teacher turnover, and hiring inexperienced teachers who tend to leave the profession at a disproportionate rate, is an unstated strategy to cut payroll costs and keep unions at bay?
Sat Apr 11, 2009 at 3:05 PMBy: Another teacher Organizing charter teachers, Chicago style To Northtown Fan re: Test Scores:

At Civitas, they measure growth. Some classes, for whatever reason, start out lower than others, and I do believe the 2008 juniors came in as freshmen much lower than did the 2007 juniors.
Mon Apr 13, 2009 at 9:56 PMBy: How did we get to this? Read this!!! Organizing charter teachers, Chicago style The Arne Duncan Myth
http://www.rethinkingschools.org/archive/23_03/arne233.shtml
Tue Apr 14, 2009 at 5:03 PMBy: Civitas Employee Organizing charter teachers, Chicago style There was never anything wrong with the teachers at the 3 Civitas campuses. I work closely with them and I see how dedicated they are with the students. Unfortunately, it is the higher ups in Civitas and Chicago International Charter School that took advantage of these hard working teachers. They have driven away many good teachers in the past few years. They have high expectations with little or no resources and support.

Isn't it funny that Doc has yet to reply to Northtown teacher? Doc is probably having someone else write an articulate response.

top
Add Your Comment

By using this service you agree not to post material that is obscene, harassing, defamatory, or otherwise objectionable. Catalyst-Chicago reserves the right to delete or move any material that it deems to be in violation of this rule, and to ban anyone who violates this rule. Reader comments are limited to 500 words.





Comment:
Just so we know you're a human and not a spammer, please answer the following question: + =
Search