Become a Catalyst member

Celebrating 25 years of Catalyst


Join the conversation

We encourage our readers to leave comments and engage in dialogue about our stories. But before you do, please check out our "rules of the road."

Subscribe to by e-mail feeds

Current Issue

The race for City Hall

Jobs and schools promise to be top issues in next year’s city elections. The mayor’s education agenda faces its toughest test in the African-American communities that gave him strong support in 2011.

Budget critics air laundry list of school cuts

With a new mandate that students have daily gym class and a policy calling for more arts instruction, school librarians are becoming increasingly rare, speakers charged at hearings on the district’s budget. At the Kennedy-King College hearing, one of three held late Wednesday, speakers also criticized cuts to Simeon High’s career education programs, cuts to welcoming schools that took in students displaced by closings, the additional money being funneled to charters and a plan to save $6 million by reorganizing bus aides for disabled students.

Rhonda McLeod worries that aides will be shuffled around and children won’t get to know them. “They need to feel safe,” said McLeod, who noted that there is already a long delay in getting bus routes set up and that she has had children get lost.

In previous years CPS officials sat stone-faced at hearings, but this year, they tried to answer questions when they could. In regard to charters, Chief Financial Officer Ginger Ostro told the audience that money follows students and CPS is funding charters because students are choosing to go to them.

Asean Johnson, the student who was featured in CNN’s “Chicagoland” speaking out against the closure of his South Side school, asked the panel whether the continued opening of charter schools puts CPS on the right side of history or on the wrong side.

“That is a question,” he said.

“We will have to reflect on that,” Ostro answered.

A number of speakers were upset that district officials blamed a big pension payment for budget problems and one CTU member pointed out previous long pension holidays, even in good years when the district could have afforded to make their entire contribution.

“Saying you don’t have money is like a gambler saying that they went to Horseshoe [casino] and then telling the landlord they have no money to pay the rent,” she said. 

More librarians lost

CPS schools are getting a $250 per pupil increase, but must pay teachers raises and are pressed to make difficult decisions—including, the speakers pointed out, to librarian positions.

Megan Cusick, who leads the CTU’s librarian task force, said last year, 140 schools lost their librarians and another 60 schools laid off their librarians this year. That means that more than half of CPS schools do not have librarians. Yet CPS promised that schools would be better resourced after the closing of 50 schools last year, she said.

Cusick was followed by Marie Szyman, president of the Chicago Teacher-Librarians, who took issue with a claim that CPS CEO Barbara Byrd-Bennett made at the last board meeting that there was a shortage of available librarians. She said she knows of 200 of them ready to go work today.  

“With the Common Core emphasis on literacy, I am mystified that libraries are closing,” she said. “How can our students become “college ready” without adequate instruction in research and exposure to literature which librarians provide?”

Figuring out exactly how many librarians are budgeted for next year is difficult. The budget only lists 21 librarians, though there are likely more. Under student-based budgeting, in which schools are given money for each student, not for specific positions, there is no money provided specifically for a librarian. Principals, along with LSCs, must decide if they want a librarian and weigh the decision against other positions they might need or want—and now the district has new policies calling for daily gym class and 120 hours of arts instruction per week.

Under the old system, schools were given one physical education teacher or librarian for every 600 students. Schools with fewer students got money for half-time positions.

“I stand before you today to ask you to prevent principals from having to make the dreaded decision ‘Do I need to close the library to hire another PE teacher?’” Syzman said.

Simeon’s career education loses out

Another principal decision that came under fire was the decision to close the electrician program at Simeon Vocational High School. Latisa Kindred said she was laid off after the principal and the network office decided the school could no longer afford the program, and that an automotive teacher was laid off as well.

Simeon’s enrollment is projected to drop by about 60 students and its budget is down by about $200,000.

Kindred told the budget panel that she had been able to get students certified as well as into a union. “Working with their hands gives students hope,” she said. “I want to know how [career education] decisions are made? What guidelines are principals given when they make these autonomous decisions?”

Asean Johnson’s mother Shoneice Reynolds said she was at a meeting at Simeon about these cuts on Tuesday night and many students came out to speak about the importance of the programs. “It was a beautiful meeting and we invited CPS and the fact that you did not come shows you do not care about our children,” she said.

Also, an older gentleman spoke about being able to make a living based on his participation with the electrician program at Simeon.

International Baccalaureate threat?

The schools that were designated to receive students from closed schools were also dealt big budget blows this year as they lost the extra transition funds and got less than the expected number of students.

Ald. Pat Dowell said two welcoming schools—Mollison and Wells Prep--are supposed to become International Baccalaureate schools, but will struggle to meet the requirements because of the cuts. Other schools have higher than average rates of homeless and special education students, she said.

“Teachers, parents and myself are worried that the loss of these resources will be another disruption for these students,” she said.

Given these cuts, parents and teachers struggled to understand why CPS keeps opening charter schools. Concept Charter School came under particular fire. Concept, which has more than a dozen campuses throughout the Midwest including three in Chicago and two more planned, was recently raided by the federal government’s Securities and Exchange Commission and is under investigation by the state board in Ohio.

One of the planned new campuses is supposed to be located in Chatham in a megachurch development, but the church’s spokeswoman has reportedly said they are not going forward until Concept works out its problems. Concept officials said 250 students have registered for the school and they are now looking for a new location.

CPS Chief Innovation Officer Jack Easley, who was part of the panel at the South Side hearing, said the district is monitoring the situation closely and will soon reveal how the situation will be handled.


George N. Schmidt wrote 27 weeks 1 day ago

Substance and Catalyst, but Sun-Times and Tribune are silent

I guess we'll have to read the "transcripts" to get more details on the budget hearings, but thanks, Catalyst, for this. Univision and Substance were at the Wright College hearing. Maybe DNA Info. The Sun-Times briefly put up a story on its website, then deleted it! There is nothing in print in the Tribune this morning. The whiteout on news as important as this is disgusting...

suntimes reader wrote 27 weeks 1 day ago


CPS officials grilled over local school cuts at budget hearing
BY LAUREN FITZPATRICK Education Reporter July 16, 2014 2:50PM
GeorgiWaller teacher LSC member Beard Elementary School spoke out against Chicago Public Schools' proposed $5.76 billi2015 budget Wednesday night public
Georgia Waller, a teacher and LSC member at Beard Elementary School, spoke out against Chicago Public Schools' proposed $5.76 billion 2015 budget Wednesday night at a public hearing at Malcolm X College. | Ashlee Rezin/for Sun-Times Media
Updated: July 17, 2014 1:59AM

The specter of 50 closed schools haunted a budget hearing Wednesday night on the West Side as dozens of people asked Chicago Public Schools officials over and over and over:

How could CPS continue to cut budgets at neighborhood schools while opening new charter and contract schools — even after shutting down a record number of schools just a year ago?

“We need to pull the money from the plan of expanding charter schools, reinvest in neighborhood schools in our communities,” said Scott Hiley, a special education teacher at Lincoln Park High School whose classes have so many desks jammed in that he has little room to move around.

George N. Schmidt wrote 27 weeks 7 min ago

Sun-Times story was missing in print and removed from Web

Sorry, "Sun-Times reader," but we subscribe to the print edition of, and they simply censored the story out of print. As to the Web publication, I saw it during the wee hours and then it disappeared beneath that tsunami of paid ads that the Sun-Times seems to think is a substitute for news. Of course, the Sun-Times wasn't as bad as the Tribune, which is becoming a tribune for the one-percent and Rahm Emanuel's version of reality. They just ignored the hearings completely.

Univision was at the Wright College hearing. They do a better job than the rest of the TV "news" outfits combined.

The most complete coverage is at Period. We had reporters at each of the three hearings, and at two we tried to cover what every speaker said -- a total of more than 50 people, each of whom was eloquent. Three aldermen spoke -- Pat Dowell, Nick Sposato, and John Arena.

You'd never know that from reading Chicago's corporate propaganda media, though.

I doubt that any other city would find its news organizations ignoring a $6 billion public budget, but here in Chicago, it's being done.

Concerned Parent wrote 26 weeks 4 days ago

Another great quote from Mr. Estvan

If I were a primary teacher I might say: “Girls and Boys now we are going to have fun with numbers. I am going to teach you how to claim savings beyond the level your school district ever budgeted for central administrative positions. It’s really fun and makes us all look like we are saving money, when in fact sometimes we are actually spending more money. Cool so let’s get to it!”
Rod Estvan

hguhf wrote 1 week 5 days ago


I like this very much,very good post.


العاب تلبيس wrote 3 sec ago

Add your comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
go here for more