Become a Catalyst member

Celebrating 25 years of Catalyst


Join the conversation

We encourage our readers to leave comments and engage in dialogue about our stories. But before you do, please check out our "rules of the road."

Subscribe to by e-mail feeds

Current Issue

The race for City Hall

Jobs and schools promise to be top issues in next year’s city elections. The mayor’s education agenda faces its toughest test in the African-American communities that gave him strong support in 2011.

Grades for Illinois education up slightly, but still low

Only one-third of Illinois students are proficient in reading at 3rd grade, begin high school academically on-track to graduate and leave high school ready for college, according to the latest Advance Illinois report on education in Illinois.

As students get older, the picture continues to be bleak. Students who don’t meet at least three college readiness standards on the ACT have only a 15 percent chance of graduating from college, according to research. Because of lack of preparation, fewer than 30 percent of Illinois students who go to college will graduate, the report projects.

Advance Illinois Executive Director Robin Steans says the finding that so few students are reading well in 3rd grade is “shocking,” even though she is immersed in the education world.

The fact that these students never catch up is a call to action, Steans said.

Another troubling finding: 15 percent of young adults are out of work and out of school, up from 13 percent in 2010, according to the report “The State We’re In.”

Illinois also has one of the worst achievement gaps in the nation. “A shockingly low 12 percent of African American students, 18 percent of Latino students and 16 percent of low-income students read proficiently in 4th grade,” according to the report. Yet the gap narrowed slightly in 8th-grade and more students of color and poor students are taking Advanced Placement exams, though few are passing them.

The biennial report issued by the powerful advocacy group is meant to pull together a variety of statistics to paint a full picture of education in the state.

Overall, the latest report gives the state slightly better grades than it did two years ago. In the area of early education, Illinois continues to get an incomplete; in elementary and high school education, the state gets a C-minus, up from a D; and in post-secondary education, it gets a C-plus, up from a C.

Yet most of the reason why Illinois did better is that it held steady, while other states declined.

“I don’t want there to be any false celebrations,” says Bill Daley, co-chair of the Advance Illinois board.

The report comes out just as the state is implementing a host of changes to the education system, from the more rigorous Common Core standards—and, eventually, new tests based on those standards—to a new teacher and principal evaluation system to a protocol to assess how many preschoolers are ready for kindergarten.

Steans says she’s hoping the report underscores the importance of implementing these new measures well.

“All these parts matter and relate to each other,” Steans says. “It is a life boat. If you are missing even one plank, you will sink.”

High school exit exams?

The report also might set the stage for new legislation to make sure that students don’t graduate from high school without the skills to get through college. About 55 percent of Illinois high school graduates go on to college, according to the report.

“College is expensive,” says Steans, noting another finding: Paying for college takes 21 percent of a typical family’s median income, a percentage that has risen since 2010.

Steans says a state committee is looking at options to ensure that students don’t go to college only to drop out, such as high school exit tests or, as an alternative, end-of-course tests that students take as they complete classes.

Yet Steans stresses that she believes the problems in college begin way before hand.

Illinois has been widely seen as a leader in providing preschool to three and four- year-olds. With 20 percent of three-year-olds in state-funded programs, Illinois is still No. 1 in the nation. However, over the past two years, the number dropped by 1 percentage point and the report notes that budget pressures may result in even fewer children have access to preschool in the future.

Illinois still gets a grade of incomplete in early childhood because it still does not have information on how many children walk into kindergarten with the age-appropriate skills and knowledge. Illinois, however, is expected in 2015 to roll out statewide a survey tool to measure school readiness.

Strengthen the ‘essential supports’

To change the scenario, the report advocates that schools focus on strengthening the essential supports—ambitious instruction, collaborative teachers, effective leaders, supportive environments and involved families—which were identified by the Consortium on Chicago School Research at the University of Chicago.

One hurdle in bringing more of these supports to schools is the growth in low-income enrollment coupled with a lack of resources for these students, according to the Advance Illinois report. One example: Illinois is ranked 43rd nationally in the ratio of students to counselors.

Advance Illinois points to Massachusetts as one of the places Illinois should emulate. Almost two decades ago, Massachusetts legislators passed a bill that, among other strategies, promised equitable funding across school districts and implemented a high school exit exam. The state also tests teachers on a general curriculum and requires them to do art and science coursework.

As a result, Massachusetts has experienced a surge in student achievement, according to the report.

Illinois stands to see some of the same improvement after the implementation of the reforms set out in recently-adopted legislation and policy, Steans says. But the improvement will not happen quickly.

The 2012 report opens with a 10-page narrative that attempts to put Illinois in context, arguing that the state is still a leader in the number of adults with college degrees but is in danger of falling behind. Also, it points out that the United States is behind other nations in academic performance.

Daley says he and other business leaders became involved with Advance Illinois out of concern that the state was not producing enough qualified workers for higher- skilled jobs. “If we don’t do something about this, our economy is going to deteriorate,” he says.

1 comment

Improving on lessons learned wrote 2 years 8 weeks ago

High school performance

The idea of high school exit exams is laughable. We already scream about excessive testing in schools. I am sure there is research on these type of tests indicating very mixed results.

CPS has had experience with exit standards at the elementary to high school transition which resulted in shifting policies and unexpected, expensive and failed remedial experiments. What additional challenging circumstances will high school exit exams bring on?

I have believed pushing AP course enrollment when AP test passage is so low was a disservice to high school students but given that grades are a better predictor to college success that ACT scores it may be a strategy to expand. The earlier in a student's life an academic intervention works the better, but high school is not too late. Use the on-track indicator to identify students for whom supporting enhanced learning in the sophomore year particularly will make a difference. Working with college level curricula in high school can be skill-building. Thereby expensive remedial course work in college is minimized and college success may be achieved.
Bertha Magana

Add your comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
go here for more