Become a Catalyst member

Celebrating 25 years of Catalyst


Join the conversation

We encourage our readers to leave comments and engage in dialogue about our stories. But before you do, please check out our "rules of the road."

Subscribe to by e-mail feeds

Current Issue

The race for City Hall

Jobs and schools promise to be top issues in next year’s city elections. The mayor’s education agenda faces its toughest test in the African-American communities that gave him strong support in 2011.

CPS to announce new teacher evaluations, says union

Catalyst Chicago has posted an updated version of this story. View it by clicking here.

CPS officials are expected to announce the district's new teacher evaluation system Friday, including a plan for incorporating test scores as part of evaluations, Chicago Teachers Union negotiators said Thursday night.

Because legally mandated negotiations between the union and the district had been going on since December- well past the minimum 90-day period specified in state law - the district is now free to implement the evaluation procedures it most recently discussed with the union.

"I have mixed feelings, and I think it remains to be seen how this will play out," said Carol Caref, coordinator of the CTU's Quest Center. "We felt like it was better than what they started with, but there were many things in it we did not agree with."

She noted that the union had gotten some concessions from the district but still has concerns about the fact that teachers cannot appeal their ratings, which under the law can affect layoff decisions and even cause some teachers to lose their licenses.

The union is also concerned about the use of value-added ratings as part of evaluations--essentially incorporating test scores into the equation--although state law mandates that at least 25 percent of teacher evaluations be based on student performance this year and 30 percent in later years. 

By law, CPS must use the new evaluations in at least 300 schools by this fall and the remainder of the district by fall 2013.

The district's plan for ratings in 2012-13, according to Caref, is as follows:

--Elementary teachers' ratings would be based 75 percent on observations under the Charlotte Danielson Framework for Teaching, 15 percent on the individual teachers' value-added scores on the NWEA assessment, and 10 percent on non-multiple-choice student performance assessments designed by teachers.

--In this example, teachers would be rated on a scale of up to 400 points. A teacher would get 10 to 40 points for performance assessments, and 75 to 300 points for their rating on the Danielson observation.

--The value-added points would be parceled out according to how far above or below average a teacher is.

--Teachers earning 100 to 219 points would be rated unsatisfactory. Those earning 220 to 284 points would be rated needs improvement. Those garnering 285 to 339 points would be rated proficient and those with at least 340 points would get a rating of excellent.

--Elementary teachers in subjects that are not tested, and in kindergarten through 2nd grade, will have 15 percent of their ratings determined by the performance assessments, and 10 percent by school-wide value-added scores for literacy.

--High school teachers in core subjects will have 90 percent of their ratings based on the Danielson framework, and 10 percent based on student performance assessments.

However, the high school rating system is likely to change dramatically in the future because it does not meet the minimum criteria set by the Illinois State Board of Education for the new evaluations under the Performance Evaluation Reform Act.

It is not clear yet how much the new rating system will cost, but CPS is hiring up to 18 central office employees to help train evaluators and make sure the new ratings are accurate. The advertised salary for the position is $78,700 to $111,000.


Anonymous wrote 2 years 41 weeks ago

Charlotte Danielson

Once again...if your principal likes you they can make you look like a gem...if they dont like you...they can make you look like a student's worst there a provision for a classroom of 34 uncontrollable kids vs 22 preselected students? it all scares me....will brizzard be evaluated???

me wrote 2 years 41 weeks ago

next step

the tribune will publish them!!

Danny wrote 2 years 41 weeks ago

No publication

The same law that establishes the new system (PERA 2010) also prohibits that the information be made public.

Of course, the Tribune may sue...

xian wrote 2 years 41 weeks ago


I think it was a negotiated package deal by the previous administration, but that law passed separately in either the 2010 veto or 2011 session.

Add your comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
go here for more