Marshall High and other turnaround high schools, in Chicago and nationally, face a thorny dilemma. Higher-performing students are being siphoned off through competition, driving down enrollment and raising tough policy questions about the future of these schools.
Recent Notebook Entries
Right Now On Notebook
By:
By:
By:
By:
Other Blogs
catalyst-chicago.org feeds
Current Issue
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CPS budget woes
By: Sarah Karp / June 12, 2010
Stepping into the role as Chicago Teachers Union president-elect on Saturday, Karen Lewis said she will not take CEO Ron Huberman's word that CPS' deficit is $600 million and that she wants a full accounting of the district's financial situation before making any concessions.
Stepping into the role as Chicago Teachers Union president-elect on Saturday, Karen Lewis said she will not take CEO Ron Huberman's word that CPS' deficit is $600 million and that she wants a full accounting of the district's financial situation before making any concessions.
"Teachers got pink slips this week and we have yet to see the real budget," she said at a press conference held Saturday morning in the foyer at King High School where Lewis is a chemistry teacher.
Lewis will immediately have to put her rhetoric to the test. On Friday, CPS officials announced that it will hold an emergency board meeting Tuesday morning to consider resolutions that would allow Huberman to lay off teachers, increase class sizes from 30 to 35 and borrow up to $800 million to cover late state payments. The board also is being asked to pass a resolution concerning the "Board's ability to fund contractual wage and salary increases with CPS union members in fiscal year 2011.
Through CPS spokeswoman Monique Bond, district officials congratulated Lewis and said "we look forward to working in partnership with the new leadership."
Lewis said that she doesn't expect many details at the board meeting on Tuesday. "Another power point," she shrugged. She said she will try to convince Huberman that these proposals are not the answer and she will propose different solutions.
In a run-off election that took place Friday, Lewis got 60 percent of the vote, defeating two-time incumbent Marilyn Stewart. Stewart, who represents the UPC, came under attack for not fighting hard against CPS-administration led efforts like closing schools and opening charters that resulted in the loss of teacher jobs.
CTU spokeswoman Rosemaria Genova did not return phone calls on Saturday.
Lewis represents and is one of the founding members of the Caucus of Rank and File Educators. CORE emerged two summers ago after Lewis and Jackson Potter, a teacher at Little Village/Lawndale High School, became frustrated with what they saw as the leadership's willingness to accept the closing of neighborhood schools and the opening of charter schools.
Joseph McDermott, a CORE delegate and teacher at Crane High School, said that over the last year CORE had pushed Stewart to take a harder stance against the CPS administration. And he said CORE's win was the result of organizing.
"We energized the grassroots," he said. "This is something Stewart didn't understand."
On Saturday, Potter said he thinks Lewis' win signals that there's been a "shift in how the public understands the reform agenda." He said CORE will be aggressive in helping charter school teachers unionize and in fighting against such things as turnarounds and merit pay. These things are unproven and waste of public money, he said.
In opposing these efforts, CORE differs from Stewart and the national American Federation of Teachers, which have taken more of a position of compromise.
Lewis laid out her position clearly on Saturday. She sees much of current reform efforts as driven by corporations. She said 15 years ago the corporations realized a lot of money was in public education and then decided to go into running charter schools and turnarounds. Now, she said it is incumbent on the union to take back public education.
"The business people do not have a clue, but they are the ones calling the shots," she said

First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
You bet. NCLB as it currently stands will be looking for 100% perfection by 2014. Horray for ill-funded education systems demanding educational perfection! Sounds like a winner to me. That is why education reform in CPS has been soooo effective and successful. I mean, look at those ISAT scores going through the roof for the past 10 or so years.
Following a model like this, the US will be near the bottom of the list of industrialized nations in educational attainment and achievement by 2014, if not sooner.
CORE's Karen Lewis wins CTU election
I am extremely happy and hopeful......
CORE's Karen Lewis wins CTU election
Yes. I am also positive about this. This proves that the people still have a voice. We are not the downtrodden teachers we have been made out to be!! Please read Sun Times analysis to understand why organization sheets were not revealed until after the election. Marilyn sold us out!!!!
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
First of all, congratulations to Karen Lewis and the CORE team on their electoral victories.
A couple of things Sarah Karp--usually a very good reporter--has got wrong in this story.
One, Karen Lewis is now the President-Elect of the Chicago Teachers Union. Her term begins July 1, and not today.
Two, Karp has misread the CPS special meeting agenda. What it says is:
"Resolution Finding that the Board of Education Has a Reasonable Expectation that Board will be Able to Fund Collectively Bargained for Wage and Salary Increases for Fiscal Year 2011"
Unless that's a typo, the Board IS going to fund our 4% raises.
It may be interesting to speculate on WHY they are doing so. My guess is that they don't want to open up the contract for negotiations and/or risk the possibility of a strike.
The other items are things they can do unilaterally.
The Union can try to embarrass the Board about certain parts of its budget, but there is nothing they can do about it. Article 48 of the Agreement, citing both the IELRA and Illinois school code, defines management rights as including the Board's "overall budget."
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
CORE believes in strength and unity, and "No man is an island, entire of itself: every man is a piece of the continent of the main..." By John Donne
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
CORE believes in strength and unity, and "No man is an island, entire of itself: every man is a piece of the continent of the main..." By John Donne
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
"We energized the grassroots," he said. "This is something Stewart didn't understand."
Sure, I guess a bunch of public sector white collar professionals with master's degrees still qualifies as grassroots.
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
In order for any progress with the budget the teachers union needs to give in a little.
A CPS teacher gets tenure after THREE YEARS. And this happens almost automatically with few exceptions.
They also have some the highest salaries and best benefits in the nation.
The union need to stop playing victim and realize that they're there to educate and they have a wonderful contract compared with private and other public institutions, and no ones out to get them.
Granted 35 students (even 30) is a ridiculous number. All of the CPS community (parents, student, community members, teachers and administration) need to work together and stop blaming the Board and Huberman, when they are not willing to compromise themselves.
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
The new president needs to acknowledge that too many of her members are not doing a good or even adequate job of educating the students in front of them, and until they do, the calls for alternatives to regular public schools will get louder. It's true that good teachers are underpaid, but too many of the rank and file are just babysitters, and poor ones at that!
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
Danny for the first time in your post, I agree with you. However, even Lewis will have to negotiate with the Board to help all teachers.
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
The press release on the upcoming emergency board meeting states the resolution as such: "Resolutions concerning the Board’s ability to fund contractual wage and salary increases with CPS union members in fiscal year 2011." My read is that the resolution (I have not seen it) will state that the board does not have the ability to pay the salary increase. I could be wrong and I will make the change in the article so that it is more ambiguous.
Of course Danny is right... Karen Lewis is the president-elect. I am sorry if my article was confusing.
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
Ms. Karp states: My read is that the resolution (I have not seen it) will state that the board does not have the ability to pay the salary increase.
Classic. Here's what the Board agenda says, since the author, an education "reporter", didn't bother to read it:
Resolution Delegating the Authority to the Chief Executive Officer to Honorably Terminate/Dismiss Tenured and Probationary Appointed Teachers Displaced as a Result of Cost Saving Measures implemented to Address Financial Exigencies for the 2010-2011 and 2011-2012 School Years, Including as a Result of increases in Class Size
(At first glance this looks to me like a CPS attempt to avoid contractual obligations to displaced teachers, i.e., placement in vacant positions and continued salaries for 10 months.)
Resolution Finding that the Board of Education Has a Reasonable Expectation that Board will be Able to Fund collectively Bargained for Wage and Salary Increases for Fiscal Year 2011.
Resolution Authorizing the Issuance of a Note of the Board of Education of the City of Chicago, Illinois, in an Aggregate Principal Amount not to Exceed $800,000,000 Pursuant to School Code
(Contractual raises will cost the Board about $100 million. And CPS is taking out an $800 million loan. But won't be making obvious cuts that would help lower class sizes and keep teachers in the classroom with students.)
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
Neighborhood schools are set up to not perform as well as they could. The onus on the problem is that fact that CPS has schools organized using the antiquated "factory model" which not the way high performing school districts organize their school day (with more instructional time) and real embedded time for teacher collaboration, which is about building professional capacity in the organization. Again, it is a serious work place issue. The problem starts at the top. That is what happens when you Daley hires a mediocre ( I am being generous) city hall manager to run a school district. The problem is that the students are paying for the lack of experience and leadership at the top, Daley and Huberman.
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
I don't know about other school districts but in CPS our contract (and our Union) does not and cannot protect poor teachers. Bad principals protect bad teachers. If there are poor teachers in the classroom it is a failure of administration.
The principal, first and foremost, is responsible for the educators in his or her own building. The buck stops there. This school leader has the authority to fire bad teachers. It is a simple process in CPS. As long as a principal follows the established procedures it is a done deal. The Union gets involved when principals do *not* follow the mutually agreed upon process.
If you'd like to learn more about how simple it is in CPS to fire a poor teacher just read the Agreement between the Board of Education and the Chicago Teachers Union. You might be surprised.
Our Union can and should play an important role in the professional development of teachers. I hope the new Union leadership makes it a priority. CPS, and their horrendous track record in support of educators, clearly has not.
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
Sarah Karp
The agenda for Tuesday's Board meeting can be found here: http://www.cps.edu/About_CPS/The_Board_of_Education/BoardAgenda/Pages/Up...
I haven't seen the press release. It's certainly possible the PR and the agenda have dissimilar wording.
I think some of the confusion on this matter is the way its worded in the contract. The raises are NOT automatic. The Board must pass the resolution that they have a "reasonable expectation" to be able to afford the raises for them to take effect. If the Board doesn't pass such a resolution, then presumably, the raises would not become effective. Most people assume it works in the reverse.
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
I stand corrected... for the record, I always do read the agendas. This was an unusual circumstance as the emergency board meeting was announced only Friday. I was actually out of the office Friday with my own children at their end-of-the-school-year festivities. I should have checked if there was an agenda Saturday and regret not doing so. It is a good thing we have astute readers to help us out. Also, I am wondering: Do you think Huberman (and Daley) are now committed to paying the teacher raises? If so, why?
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
Huberman and Daley are committed to paying the raises only because a) they are contractually obligated to do so, and b) CPS is not interested in opening its books to scrutiny if they don't. Providing for the 4% raise and firing thousands will make teachers appear greedy despite the fact that neither firing teachers nor foregoing the raise is necessary. The Board's budget priorities simply do not support the best interests of students. That is what needs to be changed.
Not in the best interest of students:
Firing thousands of teachers
*High stakes testing
*IDS (expensive mandated curricula)
*Leaving communities with NO neighborhood schools
*Poor in-school administrators
*Corporate moguls running the Board of Ed
*Feeding children slop for breakfast and lunch
*Elimination of sports and extracurricular activities
*Cars and chauffers for administrators
*A horrendously restrictive Acceptable Use Policy
*Ineffective, old-technolgy grade and student information software
*The Board deciding not to raise taxes when it could
*Hiring cheap, short-term teachers as a renewable resource (via Teach For America)
*Systematically eliminating veteran and minority educators
*Hiring nearly as many 125 S Clark administrators as are "cut"
*Failure to advocate for spending TIF money on schools
*Providing embarrassingly poor professional development to teachers
*Illegitimate formulas for determining teacher to student ratio
*Allowing massive school overcrowding in many parts of the city
*Firing outstanding veteran teachers en masse in poverty stricken, difficult schools
*Demanding principals reduce suspensions by ignoring the Student Code of Conduct
The list goes on and on...
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
I agree with all but "eliminate minority teachers"...our school 4/5 of the teachers let go at our school were "white"...so lets not go there...and dont make me start on the 10% male teachers in elem ed! lets not turnm this into a minority thing please ALL TEACHERS AT CPS ARE ON THE CHOPPING BLOCK
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
me@me.com,
I should have been more clear. There has been a significant reduction in African-American teachers due to the Renaissance 2010 initiative. This shift in the demographic of the workforce may not be intentional, but a disparate impact would be a violation of various laws. That is why the EEOC is looking into it. School closures and turnarounds, while still effecting thousands of teachers, impact a different group of teachers than your school.
The budget cuts are a different story, as you have seen in your building. The teachers laid off due to budget cuts and classroom size increases are relatively new teachers who tend to be caucasian; that is the recent hiring trend in CPS, also due, at least in part, to Ren2010.
Ultimately you are correct - there is a massive purge of teachers taking place all over the city and state. We are all on the chopping block.
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
Unfortunately, this was not the case.
I cant give specifics to our school or the stituation for legal reasons but ...it was heard that our principal wanted to get rid of "the gringos"... and she did. she let go teachers who had "excellent ratings" with more years experience and left new teachers who only taught for a year or less..
it just isnt as simple as you think...it's an attack on all teachers of all colors ....it all depends on the wims of the prinicpals and their "agendas"......be they white, black, hispanic!!
but i agree maybe african american suffered more ...but racism , as i have seen, is not only against AA or Latins...ive seen it with whites too and it makes me sick in ANY CASE
17 dollar solution
If teachers gave up 12 dollars a month in salary and every parent gave 12 per student per month in tuition our school would have 66million dollars per year??? Suburban schools ask for it...why cant we? Maybe the union could tighten its belt and allow 12 bucks to be taken off our dues and taken off our paychecks for cps savings and a lot of jobs???
Simple idea? But it would work...no sacrafice from anyone??
400000 students x $17 x 9 months = 60,000,000
40000 teachers x 17 x 9 months =6,000,000
that would = 66 million dollars. this really isnt asking much of anyone???
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
I was let go by an incompetent principal from an overcrowded, neighborhood school on the southwest side for no reason and was unsucessful in getting a grievance filed. Central office destroyed my personel files that would have allowed me to prove I was tenured. I now work at a Renn 2010 school and faring much better. I can be a more effective teacher. Don't be so quick to bash Renn 2010 because I can say they DO work in the best interest of students.
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
i would be careful on any organization that is "connected" to state funding..and CPS...once they get their way with Ren 2010? What will it be Ren 2020? Only fund schools who agree to pay teachers 15 dollars an hour?? Who knows?????
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
CEO Ron Huberman called an emergency board meeting this Tuesday.
He is still claiming a $600 million deficit, but won't show the numbers.
Now he wants to:
* To borrow $800 million and be granted the authority to fire tenured and probationary teachers, increasing class sizes to 35 per class.
Let's tell Huberman that this is unacceptable.
Emergency Picket
Tuesday, June 15th
6:00-7:00 AM
Chicago Board of Education
125 S. Clark
If you are able to attend the meeting, public participation begins at 10:00 AM.
Teachers and PSRPs need to take a zero day (no pay) to attend the meeting.
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
I was a teacher in CPS for 10 years before I left. The treatment of teachers by some administrators is goes beyond unacceptable, it is inhumane. I agree with Gracey 110%. I hope CORE can make a difference in the working conditions for CPS teachers, they really deserve better.
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
I was a teacher in CPS for 10 years before I left. The treatment of teachers by some administrators is goes beyond unacceptable, it is inhumane. I agree with Gracey 110%. I hope CORE can make a difference in the working conditions for CPS teachers, they really deserve better.
Trib's Karp
I don't subscribe or read the Trib. Never have. Never will. But I do remember when they had one or two competent ed reporters. I get that Karp was too busy with her own kids and blew it, but the fact that she asks why the Mayor and CPS are willing to fund the raises blows my mind. If her understanding of that provision of the Agreement is so shallow, certainly all her work must be suspect. Unbelievable.
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
Of all these posts I have yet to see anything that says what is going to be done in the interests of the STUDENTS !
They are always last on the list.
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
If there is time and I can get on the speakers list tomorrow Access Living will be making the following statement:
Access Living of Chicago Opposes CPS Amending its Current Policy on Class Size
Presented to the Chicago Board of Education at a Special Meeting Held on June 15, 2010
My name is Rod Estvan and I am the Education Policy Analyst for Access Living of Chicago, which is a disabilities rights organization. I am here today to speak in opposition to Board Report 10-0615-PO1 which allows the CPS CEO at his determination to increase class sizes for regular education classrooms up to 35 students for FY2011 and FY2012. This policy exempts class sizes for self contained special education classrooms which are determined by ISBE Rules and Regulations.
I speak to the adverse impact of this potential increase on students with disabilities who are educated in general education classrooms for the majority of their school day. Increasing the average size of classrooms increases pressure on general education teachers who are often required to modify curriculum for students with disabilities in these classrooms and to improve the academic skills of these students. As members of this Board are aware CPS has signed on to the Illinois Race to the Top application and has agreed to implement very major reforms in how teachers are evaluated, the State has also adopted the Performance Evaluation Reform Act of 2010 ("PERA") (Public Act 96-0861). Both of these development require that at least 50% teacher evaluations rating be based on student growth. Our fear is that general education teachers faced with larger class sizes will concentrate their efforts on remediating students most likely to show growth and hence impact their performance evaluations.
Moreover, we have real concerns over this pressure forcing some students with disabilities into segregated educational settings and reversing positive trends the CPS has experienced over the last ten years. The Individual Education Plan (IEP) for CPS students currently in place are based on the presumption of existing class sizes for the time they are in regular education classrooms. The proposed alteration of the existing class sizes raise real concerns for those of us in the advocacy community as to whether what may take place will constitute a massive violation of existing IEPs.
Access Living fully supports CPS and the State of Illinois in holding teachers accountable for effectively educating students with disabilities, something which has not often been done up to now unless CPS has been litigated against. But it is not just teachers who are accountable, it is the Board of Education which is also accountable for providing the conditions where success and improvement can be realized. The 35 student classroom does not lay the foundation for such success.
Access Living would urge the CPS to look at other alternatives than simply what is stated in the proposed class size policy, which is that unions agree to major contract modifications including eliminating agreed upon salary increases. Among the alternatives not discussed in any presentation up to now, are increasing property taxes to the maximum allowable by law, eliminating the summer bridge program, and radically curtailing expenditures for turnaround programs for several school years. The maximum amount of savings from this class size increase proposal is only $160 million based on power point presentations CPS gave earlier this year, there are other paths to this $160 million savings that CPS has yet to critically examine.
Access Living is fully aware of the State level crisis in education funding. In fact we have worked effectively and collaboratively with CPS in Springfield during the last session of the General Assembly. But at least for now, that well has run dry, and CPS needs to examine all sacred cows, including property taxes to prevent this proposed increase in classroom size. Taking away salary increases from teachers should only be on the table once all other options have been exhausted beyond the budget reductions CPS has already implemented.
First agenda item for new CTU president Karen Lewis: Confront CP
Notice how the majorheadlines dont say up to 3500 layoff in thier headlines?? The Blackhawks lose one game and its pasted all over the front page? 3000 teacher and 35 kids to a room? Who cares?? Its just middle class teachers and poor students??
These headlines look like the greedy teachers are going to get a raise?
These are the headlines??
Cps Chicago - News Results CPS to borrow $800M, boost teacher pay 4% Chicago Sun-Times - Jun 12 02:15am
CPS Student Fatally Shot at Party FOX News Chicago - Jun 13 03:14pm
CPS To Borrow $800M, Boost Teacher Pay By 4% Chicagoist - Jun 13 11:51am
Add your comment