Pacing of Math Instruction

September 1, 1998

Pacing of Math Instruction

Table of Contents

Woodlawn school shows what can be done

Elizabeth Duffrin

McCosh Elementary School in Woodlawn is a school that has beaten the odds.

With a large, poor and unstable student population, it fits the statistical profile of schools with the lowest expectations for student learning, according to the Consortium on Chicago School Research. The school enrolls nearly 1,000 students in kindergarten through 8th grade; 97 percent are low income. Its mobility rate, the percentage of students that transfer in or out during the school year, at last count was 47 percent.

The overwhelming majority of Chicago schools with similar demographics are...

Resources

Elizabeth Duffrin

In the early 1990s, the National Science Foundation began funding the development of programs that would teach math at a higher conceptual level while also engaging students in interesting, real-world problems. After extensive field testing, most are just now becoming commercially available.

The differences between NSF-funded programs and traditional texts "are many, profound and subtle," notes Prof. Eric Robinson of Ithaca College, who is reviewing the programs.To understand the content and teaching strategies, teachers will need professional development, he says. "You don't just...

Math teaching in U.S. 'inch deep, mile wide'

Elizabeth Duffrin

Math instruction in the United States is "an inch deep and a mile wide," leaving students with little knowledge because teachers try to cover too much territory, according to a massive international comparison of student achievement and teaching practices. Compared to teachers in countries with higher math achievement, American teachers are tackling an ever wider range of math topics each year, the Third International Math and Science Study (TIMSS) found.

"In other countries, they might spend a month on a topic while we spend days on a topic," says William Schmidt, the U.S....

9,360 lesson plans on the way

Elizabeth Duffrin

As school opens, central office is rolling out drafts of daily lesson plans in math, science, language arts and social studies for every grade in the school system—9,360 lesson plans in all.

Officially titled a "structured curriculum," they are pegged to the system's learning standards, and they're aimed principally at teachers who are new, uncertified in their subject areas or just "burned out or worn out or preoccupied with classroom management," Chief Executive Officer Paul Vallas told the National Science Board at a recent Chicago hearing on math and science education reform....

Middle-grade math stuck on basic skills

Elizabeth Duffrin

Recalling her 8th-grade math class, 15-year-old Samantha, now a sophomore at a North Side public high school, shakes her head with exasperation. "The first half of the year was nothing but fractions. We started out with 'what a fraction is.'"

Fractions were old hat to Samantha—she'd learned them in 6th grade and relearned them in 7th. But her classmates were slow to catch on, she says. "These kids, you could sit there and tell them, 'It's a fraction!' and the next day they would be like, 'What is that?'" That's why the teacher kept reviewing. "She didn't like anybody to fail. She...

Board's main effort winding down

Elizabeth Duffrin

The Chicago Systemic Initiative (CSI), part of a five-year, multi-city project of the National Science Foundation, is the main contribution central office has made to teacher training in math and science.

With only $15 million over five years, CSI seeks to do a lot without a lot of money, says program director Clifton Burgess.

Its aim is to upgrade math and science education systemwide. Its approach is to help schools craft and carry out their own math and science improvement plans. To do that, CSI provides modest amounts of training, support and money, an average of $7,000...

Respect for parents and kids. Professional development for teachers. Consequences for not trying. And more money—in certain areas. These are among the themes that emerge from essays our readers have written on what they believe matters most in school improvement. While most of the essays in this issue describe what Chicagoans are doing to invigorate schools and raise student achievement, several highlight problems.

Respect for parents and kids. Professional development for teachers. Consequences for not trying. And more money—in certain areas. These are among the themes that emerge from essays our readers have...
Read More

There is much to celebrate in the improvement in student achievement in the elementary schools of Chicago. Since 1990, the percentage of students scoring at or above national norms in reading has increased by 11.2 percentage points, while the percentage in math has increased by 12.5 points. After some small decreases from 1990 to 1992, as newly empowered schools were getting organized under school-based management reforms, progress was fairly steady in both reading and math. But there is still more to do.

There is much to celebrate in the improvement in student achievement in the elementary schools of Chicago. Since 1990, the percentage of students scoring at or above national norms in reading has...
Read More

When School Reform first began in 1988, I participated wholeheartedly in the reform activities, committees and training. As a 12-year teacher, I'd had my share of bad experiences with a bloated central bureaucracy, dictatorial principals, poorly designed curriculum and inadequate teaching materials, and I hoped to be part of the solution for improving schools. From my perspective as classroom teacher, improving schools meant improving instruction and student learning. Ten years later, these two things are still what matter most to me.

When School Reform first began in 1988, I participated wholeheartedly in the reform activities, committees and training. As a 12-year teacher, I'd had my share of bad experiences with a bloated...
Read More

One of the most important contributing factors to a successful school experience is the quality of early literacy instruction. Students who have had good early literacy instruction are more likely be able to read and write without difficulty. The recent increase in the number of preschool and Reading Recovery programs, and the addition of early-intervention summer school programs have been a plus for Chicago youngsters.

One of the most important contributing factors to a successful school experience is the quality of early literacy instruction. Students who have had good early literacy instruction are more likely be...
Read More

In 1992, the School Achievement Structure (SAS) was formed at DePaul University to help low-achieving schools in Chicago adopt 10 routines that, research had shown, could turn them into high achievers.The research was conducted in Pittsburgh and Dallas while I was on the faculty of the University of Pittsburgh. The schools we studied had predominantly African-American student bodies, were located in low-income, high-crime neighborhoods, and were not magnet schools. Yet, all produced high student achievement.

In 1992, the School Achievement Structure (SAS) was formed at DePaul University to help low-achieving schools in Chicago adopt 10 routines that, research had shown, could turn them into high...
Read More

The one policy action that could make the most difference at this stage of school reform would be a serious reduction in class size. Since this is also the most expensive action, it will happen only when community organizations and the Chicago Teachers Union join forces to demand such a change.

I taught high school in the Chicago Public Schools for 34 years. The high school teachers I know want fewer students in their own classes, but many recognize that significantly lowering class size in the elementary schools would give them better prepared students.

The one policy action that could make the most difference at this stage of school reform would be a serious reduction in class size. Since this is also the most expensive action, it will happen only...
Read More

As a mother of three boys who are growing up in Little Village, the quality of our local schools is one of my main concerns. For the most part, my experience with the schools available to us has not been very positive, but recently I have begun to have some hope.

As a mother of three boys who are growing up in Little Village, the quality of our local schools is one of my main concerns. For the most part, my experience with the schools available to us has not...
Read More

Picture these scenes from the lives of Chicago public schools:Middle-school students from 11 neighborhood schools across the city work their way through a professional art gallery that has on display 400 works of outstanding quality. The show includes installations, sculpture, masks, paintings and remarkable writing about personal and social issues. All were created by the students who fill the gallery today, alternating between articulate docent and respectful listener and observer.

Picture these scenes from the lives of Chicago public schools:Middle-school students from 11 neighborhood schools across the city work their way through a professional art gallery that has on display...
Read More

Reform efforts across this city are improving education for children. Now we need to stand tall and affirm our beliefs: A quality educational program needs consistent, fair, equitable and increased funding from all levels of government, city, state and federal.Let's take technology—very costly to fund. Every school has a different level of commitment to it. Yet, all children should be afforded the opportunity to take advantage of technology's vast potential for increasing achievement.

Reform efforts across this city are improving education for children. Now we need to stand tall and affirm our beliefs: A quality educational program needs consistent, fair, equitable and increased...
Read More

In December 1986, a small group of South Shore residents met in the dining room of a parent's home to discuss the growing concerns about the education offered by the neighborhood high school. A month later, the Coalition for Improved Education in South Shore, or CIESS, was born. CIESS initially focused on improving South Shore High School but later expanded to include its feeder elementary schools. In the process, we grew from a group of residents concerned about one school to a network of 10 schools plus community organizations, businesses, institutions and, still, individual residents.

In December 1986, a small group of South Shore residents met in the dining room of a parent's home to discuss the growing concerns about the education offered by the neighborhood high school. A month...
Read More

Ten years ago, during the debate over the historic Chicago School Reform Law, Parents United for Responsible Education (PURE) and other parent groups fought for and won a parent majority on local school councils. PURE took this position because we believed that parents, who have the most at stake in schools, should have the greatest voice in governing them.

Ten years ago, during the debate over the historic Chicago School Reform Law, Parents United for Responsible Education (PURE) and other parent groups fought for and won a parent majority on local...
Read More

Over the past 22 years, the Chicago Annenberg Challenge has committed almost $28 million in grants to more than 40 school networks. The Challenge funds networks—at least three schools and an external partner such as a community group, university or reform organization—because schools cannot achieve whole-school change alone. In networks, schools are able to share resources, learn from each others' experiences, support each other and act as critical friends.

Over the past 22 years, the Chicago Annenberg Challenge has committed almost $28 million in grants to more than 40 school networks. The Challenge funds networks—at least three schools and an external...
Read More

Motivation. Motivation. Motivation. That is the key word for success these days in the Chicago public schools. Students must be motivated, parents must be motivated, teachers must be motivated, and yes, even principals must be motivated.The Reform Board of Trustees might call it accountability, but those of us in schools see it as motivation. Those of us whose schools are on probation are really motivated to get off, and those not on probation are motivated to stay off.

Motivation. Motivation. Motivation. That is the key word for success these days in the Chicago public schools. Students must be motivated, parents must be motivated, teachers must be motivated, and...
Read More

In the more than 10 years that I've been working in Chicago public elementary schools, I've watched quite a few education reform groups and initiatives come and go. In some instances, I was one of the "reformers"; in others, only an interested observer; in still others, I had to help settle the dust after the (so-called) reformers lost interest (i.e., funding). Through these experiences I've developed a list of reminders to myself that I keep posted in my office.

In the more than 10 years that I've been working in Chicago public elementary schools, I've watched quite a few education reform groups and initiatives come and go. In some instances, I was one of...
Read More

One of the things that matters most in school reform is the opportunity for parents to get more involved in their children's school and education. My children's school, Darwin Elementary, along with the Logan Square Neighborhood Association (LSNA) and three other elementary schools formed an Annenberg Challenge Network where one of our main goals was more meaningful parent involvement with students and teachers. It's the basis for our Parent-Teacher Mentor Program, where parents receive training and then work a minimum of 100 hours a semester in a classroom.

One of the things that matters most in school reform is the opportunity for parents to get more involved in their children's school and education. My children's school, Darwin Elementary, along with...
Read More

PRINCIPALS

Percentage of principals new since LSCs began hiring them in 1989: 83

Percentage of principals hired from inside the Chicago Public School system: 95

Percentage of principals hired from inside the same school: 90

Source: Financial Research and Advisory Committee

TEACHERS

Courses in reading instruction required to teach elementary school in Illinois: 1

Percentage of Chicago elementary school principals who said half or fewer of their teachers had a good grasp of language arts instruction: 33

PRINCIPALS Percentage of principals new since LSCs began hiring them in 1989: 83 Percentage of principals hired from inside the Chicago Public School system: 95 Percentage of principals hired...
Read More

Become a Catalyst member

go here for more